Wednesday, October 17, 2012

Kindergarteners decide- Was Columbus a hero or a villain?

Columbus was a hero
Maddie thinks he is a hero because he made our maps and said the world was round.
Ryan thinks he is a hero because he discovered our land and made our maps and said the world was round.
George thinks he is a hero because he made maps and proved the world was round and that there were no monsters and he found our land.
Autumn thinks he is a hero because he told people the earth is round and made sure there weren’t any monsters and sailed in 3 boats.
Naveen thinks a hero because he made our world that we can live on.
Conor thinks he is a hero because he found our land.
Columbus was a Villain
Sarah thinks he is a villain because he put chains on people and took people and stole spices and silk and gold and people.  He also killed people and spread germs which is not nice.  And he put chains on people.
Alexander thinks he was a villain because he stole gold and spices.
Cheyenne thinks he is a villain because he stole spices and people and gold.  He gave germs.
Kiani thinks he is a villain because he stole spices and took gold and he chained people and took people and killed people and spread germs.
Nicholas thinks he is a villain because he put chains on people and killed people.  He took spices and people and drove off with the boat.
Seamus thinks he is a villain because he stole spices and gold.
Peyton thinks he is a villain because he stole people, gold, and spices.
Michaela thinks he is a villain because he stole spices and gold and killed people and put our germs and killed some people.
Finn thinks he is a villain because he stole silk and spices and got germs around and killed some people and put some people in chains.
River thinks he is a villain because he stole people and put chains on people and he stole spices and gold.
Danny thinks he is a villain because he stole spices and gold and people and put chains on people.
Logan thinks he is a villain because he stole people, spices, and gold.
Cody thinks he is a villain because he stole people and gold.

Columbus was a hero and a villain
Matthew thinks a hero and a villain because he kind of did the same thing over and over again.
Ethan thinks he is a villain and a hero because he stole people but he also made good maps.

No comments:

Post a Comment